Anime Recommendations from Kiniest

Air TV (6/10) -
About a starving man looking for a girl with wings who stumbles upon a sweet teenage girl named Misuzu, and moves in with her. (Romance, Tragedy)

Bakemonogatari (8/10) -
After surviving a vampire attack, Araragi finds himself involved in a large amount of incidents involving apparations. (Mystery, Romance, Supernatural)

Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai (5/10) [S2: 6/10] -
About a group of kids trying to make friends through a club. (Comedy, School)

Bokurano (7/10) -
A group of children stumble upon a robot, and find that they must control it. However, the costs of doing so are larger then they first appear. (Psychological, Tragedy, Mecha)

Chihayafuru (8/10) -
A young woman strives to become the queen of karuta, a traditional Japanese game. (Josei, Slice of life, Comedy, Sports)

Clannad (7/10) [AS: 9/10] -
A delinquient highschool student gets involved with a shy held-back girl. (Slice of life, Comedy, Drama, School, Romance)

Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni (7/10) [S2 8/10] -
After becoming friends with the Hinamizawa residents, Keiichi begins to become very paronoid. Warning: Blood and Paranoia. (Horror, Psychological)

Kaiba (8/10) -
A dystopian world in which the mind can be transfered to other bodies. WARNING: Some mature themes. (Science Fiction, Romance)

Last Exile (8/10) -
In a world where water is precious, Claus Valca and Lavie head strive to cross the Grand Stream, a sound barrier seperating the rich and the poor. (Adventure, War)

Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica (9/10) [HIGH RECOMMENDATION] -
Madoka, a young girl who lacks self-confidence, is offered the opportunity to become a magical girl. As enthralling as the offer sounds, what really lies behind the job of becoming a magical girl? (Psychological, Magical Girl, Tragedy)

Nana (10/10) -
Two girls with the same name move into the same apartment. Life ensues. WARNING: Mature themes, meaning, not just blood and gore. This is the real deal in terms of mature themes, here. (Slice of life, Drama, Tragedy)

Neko no Ongaeshi (8/10) -
A Ghibli film, but a less popular one, thus why it's on the list. A young girl is forced to marry a cat prince. (Adventure)

Psycho-Pass (8/10) -
In a world where your mental state is analyzed by the Sybil System, latent criminals must be locked away or killed.

Shinsekai Yori (9/10) -
After the introduction of PK, the world changed dramatically. Now, after discovering the sickening secrets of their own world, 5 children find their lives threatened. (Drama, Sci-Fi, Supernatural)

Steins;Gate (8/10) -
A self proclaimed "mad scientist" ends up building a time machine. What follows is the realization that life isn't just a game. WARNING: Blood. (Science Fiction, Tragedy, Comedy)

Usagi Drop (8/10) -
A man adopts his grandfather's illegitimate 8 year old child. (Slice of life, Josei)

-----------------
(x/10) refers to my personal ratings.

Anyways, give one of these a shot, Naruto and One Piece aren't the only anime out there, you know~!