Matt vs Tabitha

Matt! He's the big buff Archie lookalike and I find his love for his "bro" hilarious. Sorry Tabitha! I would've picked you if you looked the same as in the original Hoenn anime but you do not and therefore I no longer find you too interesting a character. </3 But the joke about him looking like a Makuhita is always pretty funny, aha.

 

I prefer Tabitha (although I prefer Team Aqua in general). Tabitha just seems like an intelligent, well-rounded Admin.

As for Matt... all I have to say is; steroid abuse seriously isn't funny.

 

I liked Matt. Sure he was kind of a ditz, but he was cool. He's so funny and hilarious with the way he acts. He's great. I think he's one of the more memorable NPCs with how large and interesting he is. He's one of the stereotypical buff guys, but that's what makes him great.

 

I always found Tabitha a bit of a weird guy, so I personally prefer Matt. Matt is, as stated above, the stereotypical huge and muscular guy, which I find really funny I imagine Matt always having a smile on his face, even after he just lost a battle against you. Actually that kind of reminds me of Wattson xD

 

Tabitha for sure. He has a funny design, and overall he is a hilarious character. Matt was so boring and a typical muscly strong dude character. Sorry but he was way too bland. I don't think I'm gonna remember Matt later at all.

 

Honestly it's tied.
Matt is so cute with his bro stuff, but Tabitha is very expressive and funny. I guess I'll say Tabitha because he's really growing on me more.

 

Matt by far. I thought Tabitha was a little bit of a cop-out, to be honest. The design of his character was not what I was expecting at all.

 

I personally like Tabitha more. His overworld sprite is a bit more appealing to me, and that little evil smile he makes is just perfect.

 

Matt is adorable, unlike Tabitha, which in my opinion is too fat for words. Matt will smush you into little pieces, but he'll be happy to do that for Arche. As for Tabitha, he's more of a geek like the rest of Magma. So, I go with Matt.

 

I would have to go with Matt. Just read some of these quotes. xD

"Oho! Good idea, bro! That's my funny little man! You, me, and our Pokémon are gonna have a real good time later! A no-holds-barred barrage, bro! Oho! Hoohahahah!"

"I love interesting, strong dudes! That's why I love my bro, Archie! And that's why I'm gonna start loving you from now on, too! Next time I see you, I'll smash you up real good, OK?"

"... While we were battling it out... My bro Archie finished getting ready... ... I have only one hope... For my bro Archie to finish doing what he set out to do... That's all... My bro Archie is everything to me... I live to serve my bro..."

This guy lives to serve his bro. Now that is truly hilarious.

 

I think I have to choose Tabitha. It was funny watching him ramble and repeatedly say the word "really" before he battles you at Mt. Chimney. Matt was weird, but at least it feels like he takes pleasure in being defeated.

 

I like Matt more. His text implies some forbidden love going on there.

 

I like both of them, but Matt is my favorite! I love his kind of 'bro' attitude and how he genuinely cares about Archie and the rest of the team. He's a really cool character, I liked his involvement in the story.